What if your loved one refuses treatment?
Is it a good idea to use legal force?
Involuntary Treatment:
Myths and Facts
MYTH:
People with mental illness will not receive treatment voluntarily.
A theory, popular on the Internet, but little supported by evidence, is that the condition called “anosognosia” (“lack of insight”) is the main reason for why mentally ill people refuse hospitalization and medication. According to this theory, they simply don’t understand that treatment is good for them.
Of course, this is true in some cases – there are all kinds of people who don’t know what’s good for them and do not follow sound medical advice, leading to harmful consequences.
What is not true is that “lack of insight” is widespread among people with severe mental illness and is the primarily cause for refusing psychiatric medications.
FACTS:
A study of “individuals with a serious mental illness” published in 2016 did not find any single reason for their unwillingness to receive treatment. Researchers found that people may not want treatment, because:
they “feel the treatment is not working”
they “feel mistrustful, or coerced”
“treatment may be difficult to get to”
Since then, other studies confirmed that people often avoid treatment because of their prior bad experiences with mental health services.
Tens of thousands of people diagnosed with schizophrenia give their consent to participate in clinical trials of antipsychotic medications, which means that they want help and take medications willingly.
Wealthy people with serious mental illness willingly seek treatment in unlocked, non-coercive private residential programs. They voluntarily stay in the facility for the duration of treatment, or for as long as their family can pay.
In a study, patients who met criteria for civil commitment were randomly assigned either to an unlocked peer-run respite, or to a locked-up hospital ward. Those in the respite stayed there willingly and showed better outcomes than those who were hospitalized. This again shows that most people who do not want to be in a psychiatric hospital, refuse treatment not because of their “lack of insight,” but because they don’t like the hospital.
If you find a good facility with a friendly, sympathetic staff and a nice environment, where patients are treated with dignity and respect and the employees know how to build trust and to obtain informed consent, there will be no need to force your loved to get treatment — they would be willing to receive treatment there.
MYTH: Involuntary treatment prevents violence
FACTS ABOUT PSYCHIATRIC TREATMENT AND VIOLENCE
First of all, people with mental illness who do not abuse substances are no more violent than the general population.
Some people with psychiatric diagnoses do assault family members and, in very rare cases, strangers. If somebody is threatening and aggressive, they, of course, need to be taken into custody to protect people around them. In some cases, custody may mean hospital. However, if a person shows signs of mental illness, but does not threaten or assault anyone, this person is not dangerous.
It is not a good idea to force them into treatment out of fear that they may become violent in the future.
Hospitalization and medication do not prevent violence. In fact, they make some people commit violence for the first time in their life.
Studies show that involuntary psychiatric hospitalization increases the risk of suicide, and patients become a greater danger to selves after they are released.
What about danger to others? Does involuntary commitment help public safety? Until recently, there has been no data.
The first ever study of involuntary hospitalization (civil commitment) and violence appeared in 2025 (see here for a plain language summary). It indicates that involuntary hospitalization, on average, makes people more aggressive and more dangerous not only to themselves, but to others as well.
So, “preventive” involuntary commitment of people who did not commit any actual violence is generally bad for public safety — they are MORE likely to commit violence after they are released.
Most famous crimes by people with a mental illness diagnosis were committed after hospitalization:
Andrea Yates killed her children two days after she was discharged from a psychiatric hospital;
Andrew Goldstein pushed Kendra Webdale under a train soon after his thirteenth voluntary hospitalization;
The pilot Andreas Lubitz, who intentionally flew a plane into the French Alps, had been hospitalized and released as “fully recovered”;
The Virginia Tech shooter Seung-Hui Cho killed 32 people and himself four months after he was hospitalized overnight, underwent a “risk assessment” and was found “safe” to be released.
According to what is known about these individuals from the media, none of them had assaulted anyone before their hospitalizations. If your family member shows signs of mental illness, there is no reason to believe that you and other people will be safer if this person is hospitalized.
TO BE CONTINUED - VISIT US AGAIN SOON
